2016: Payton played in 17 games, starting in 16 of them. She recorded six goals and six assists for a total of 18 points on the season.

2015: Payton played in all 19 games. She scored four goals and assisted two for the Blue Jays. She was named to the SLIAC Academic All-Conference Team. 

2014: Payton played in 15 games and had 1 assist.

Personal: Payton is the daughter of Terry and Melinda Beeler and has three siblings: Morgan, McKenna and Jaxon.