Class of '00: A four-time letter winner in both volleyball and basketball, Whitaker was a three-time all-conference performer in basketball, while setting three school records and finishing her career in the top five in scoring (4th), rebounding (3rd), and assists (3rd). During her four-year volleyball career, Whitaker collected all-league honors four times and she earned Conference Newcomer of the Year honors as a freshman, and was the SLIAC Player of the Year as both a junior and a senior, when she earned back-to-back Westminster Female Athlete of the Year awards. Whitaker guided the Blue Jays to conference volleyball titles in 1996, 1998 and 1999, and an NCAA tournament berth in 1999. Whitaker holds Westminster College school records for assists in a season (1,237), assists in a career (4,384), and service aces in a career (156).

Inducted into the SLIAC Hall of Fame in 2008.